meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Hot Takes & Deep Dives

Jonah Wheeler on Quitting Broadway to Become a S*x Work Sensation

Hot Takes & Deep Dives

Jess Rothschild

Tv & Film

4.5774 Ratings

🗓️ 23 February 2026

⏱️ 50 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Jess is joined by Broadway composer / orchestrator / adult star JONAH WEELER! (@showoffjonah). Topics — blind items about this worst Broadway experiences, music directing Sweeney Todd Off Broadway and the final straw that pushed him toward a full-on career pivot to OnlyFans. Plus: beating Instagram censorship, creating a new cabaret about that pivot with partner John Coons, the origin story of his p*rn name "Jonah Weeler" (he is the artist formerly known as Matt Aument) and more!


⭐ IG: @jessxnyc 


⭐ Jonah Weeler & John Coons in NYC - Mar 22


⭐ Jess' docu-series on the history, mystique & lore of Fire Island — 

Finding Fire Island

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Welcome back to Hot Takes and Deep Dives, and you might know my next guest from two very different corners of showbiz.

0:23.5

Jonah Wheeler is a musical theater director and composer, orchestrator.

0:28.3

Your work has been performed by everyone from Kristen Chenoweth to Molly Pope,

0:33.3

but you kind of left Broadway and musical theater behind to become an only fan star and an internet, I guess, sensation.

0:44.3

I'm very compelled by this juxtaposition.

0:47.5

Hi, Jonah Wheeler.

0:48.7

Hello, how are you?

0:49.7

I'm great.

0:50.2

How are you?

0:50.8

I'm delighted.

0:52.0

Yeah.

0:52.4

So I was introduced to you. I was on vacation with two of my really close friends, Ben Rimmelauer and Dan Fortune.

1:00.8

And we were in Puerto Vallada and they said, by the way, we are going to this show.

1:05.8

It's Jonah Wheeler and John Coons. And they're a couple. And like one of them was a theater director.

1:10.8

He's now doing porn. And And, like, one of them was a theater director.

1:28.1

He's now doing porn. And I'm like, what? So. I'm still shocked. I'm, like, the only one. Are you the only one? I'm not technically the only one. There was a, I'm a, to be specific, I'm not a director. I'm a music director, which is like down in the pit playing piano conducting. I don't do the stage organization.

1:31.2

But there is another theater musician.

1:34.5

Well, no, I'm being entirely incorrect about this.

1:38.7

There is a actor who is in, I think, the 42nd Street Revival.

1:42.9

So this is like 20 years ago who went on to have a career in porn and then sort of flirted back with like piano bar kind of stuff. Okay. But, you know, since then, I don't know anybody else who's doing it in that kind of a way. Listen, that was the hook. I mean, I guess that's the hook of this episode as well. But like, that was enough to be like, all right, like, I'm interested. And then we said hi. We met briefly at Mark Hartman's show at Act 2.

2:02.9

Yes.

2:03.5

Turns out we have a couple mutual friends.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Jess Rothschild, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Jess Rothschild and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.