meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
True Crime Historian

Guilty Or Not, They Hung Him Twice

True Crime Historian

Richard O Jones

True Crime, Performing Arts, Documentary, Arts, Society & Culture

4.5720 Ratings

🗓️ 2 November 2025

⏱️ 53 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

The Botched Execution of George H. Painter

Jump To AD FREE SAFE HOUSE EDITION


Episode 27 starts shortly after midnight, the night of  May 17, 1891, when George H. Painter awoke the people living in his Chicago house shortly after midnight, shouting that his common law wife Alice Martin had been murdered. Painter himself went to fetch the police, who promptly arrested him for the murder. The trial made it a cut and dry case, and Painter was sentenced to hang, although he insisted his innocence up to the very end. His lawyers continued to investigate while Painter sat on death row, presented affidavit after affidavit to shadow the case with doubt, but not enough to convince a resolute governor.

Here are more stories about BOTCHED EXECUTIONS

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/true-crime-historian--2909311/support.

CLICK HERE to reserve your bunk at The Safe House, where the past is present and the rent is just a buck a week but gives you access to ad-free editions of over 400 episodes in the dusty vault, early access to all new episodes, exclusive content, access to the big boss, and whatever personal services you require.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Buffalo, Illinois, December 29, 1914.

0:10.0

R. W. Baxter, about 70 years old, said that one night in September, about four years ago,

0:17.0

he was camping near the side of a new branch railroad in eastern Montana.

0:22.0

He had come there to work on the construction of the line, but had not found a job.

0:27.2

He started a fire along the road.

0:30.1

Another man came up to him whom he had never seen before.

0:33.6

Were you ever in Chicago, the man asked.

0:36.9

Baxter said he had been. Did you know a man named George Painter?

0:42.3

Baxter said he had known a man of that name who killed a girl and was hanged for it in 1894.

0:48.9

George Painter never killed that girl, replied the stranger. How do you know, said Baxter? I know, because I killed her,

0:57.5

replied the stranger. You're a damn fool to tell about it then, was Baxter's response. The man gave his

1:05.2

name as Jack Cade. He did not remain with Baxter, and gave no further details regarding his statement.

1:14.1

Baxter said he feared becoming mixed up with the case, but had been worried by the incident

1:19.0

and wrote to the Chicago police with the idea of communicating with Painter's family that the

1:24.3

disgrace might be lifted.

1:26.8

Baxter, on account of his age, is considered not

1:30.3

entirely dependable, but told his story clearly and without reserve. Later, he expressed

1:37.3

the wish that he had kept it to himself, because he feared evil might come of it to him.

1:56.0

Chicago, Illinois, May 17, 1891.

2:03.5

Alice Martin, a disreputable woman 28 years old, was mysteriously murdered in her room at number 86 South Green Street at 1 o'clock this morning. George H. Painter, 35 years old,

2:10.6

who has been known to be a lover of the woman, is under arrest at the Displained Street

2:15.1

Station on suspicion of being connected with the crime.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Richard O Jones, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Richard O Jones and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.