meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
History Unplugged Podcast

George Washington’s Team of Rivals: How His Cabinet Forefathered One of America’s Most Powerful Institutions

History Unplugged Podcast

History Unplugged

Society & Culture, History

4.23.7K Ratings

🗓️ 9 July 2020

⏱️ 46 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

The U.S. Constitution never established a presidential cabinet—the delegates to the Constitutional Convention explicitly rejected the idea. So how did George Washington create one of the most powerful bodies in the federal government?

On November 26, 1791, George Washington convened his department secretaries—Alexander Hamilton, Thomas Jefferson, Henry Knox, and Edmund Randolph—for the first cabinet meeting. Why did he wait two and a half years into his presidency to call his cabinet? Because the U.S. Constitution did not create or provide for such a body. Washington was on his own.

Faced with diplomatic crises, domestic insurrections, and constitutional challenges—and finding congressional help lacking—Washington decided he needed a group of advisors he could turn to. He modeled his new cabinet on the councils of war he had led as commander of the Continental Army. In the early days, the cabinet served at the president’s pleasure. Washington tinkered with its structure throughout his administration, at times calling regular meetings, at other times preferring written advice and individual discussions.

Todays guest, Lindsay M. Chervinsky, author of the book The Cabinet: George Washington and the Creation of an American Institution, reveals the far-reaching consequences of Washington’s choice. The tensions in the cabinet between Hamilton and Jefferson heightened partisanship and contributed to the development of the first party system. And as Washington faced an increasingly recalcitrant Congress, he came to treat the cabinet as a private advisory body to summon as needed, greatly expanding the role of the president and the executive branch.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Renault

0:30.0

The History of North America podcast is a sweeping historical saga of the United States, Canada,

0:40.0

and Mexico from their deep origins to our present epoch. Join me, Mark Vinet, on this exciting,

0:47.0

fascinating epic journey through time, focusing on the compelling, wonderful, and tragic stories

0:52.8

of North America's inhabitants, heroes, villains, leaders, environment, and geography. I invite you to come along for the ride.

1:12.8

History is in just a bunch of names, and dates, and facts. It's the collection of all the stories throughout human history

1:19.8

that explained how and why we got here. Welcome to the History Unplugged Podcast, where we look at the forgotten, neglected, strange, and even counterfactual stories that made our world what it is.

1:31.8

I'm your host, Scott Rank.

1:41.8

One of the most powerful bodies in the American federal government is the presidential cabinet.

1:46.8

This is a private advisory board for the president, but what's interesting is that the US Constitution never established a presidential cabinet.

1:54.8

In fact, the delegates to the Constitutional Convention rejected the idea. And in fact, for the first two and a half years of George Washington's first administration, he didn't have a cabinet.

2:03.8

So why did he create one? How did it become one of the most powerful bodies in the federal government?

2:09.8

And why is it something that can just about determine whether a presidency fails or succeeds? Consider the Doris Kern's Goodwin book, Team of Rivals, where she argues that the way that Abraham Lincoln set up his cabinet was what allowed him to win the Civil War.

2:23.8

I'm looking into this topic today with Lindsay Trevinsky, who's the author of the new book, The Cabinet, George Washington, and the creation of an American institution.

2:31.8

The story starts in 1791 when George Washington convened his department secretaries Alexander Hamilton, Thomas Jefferson, Henry Knox, and M and Randolph for the first cabinet meeting.

2:40.8

The US Constitution didn't create or provide for such a body, so Washington was on his own.

2:45.8

This group of advisors was based on the councils of war that Washington held as commander of the continental army.

2:51.8

And it helped him overcome diplomatic crises, domestic insurrections, like a whiskey rebellion in 1794, and constitutional conventions. And he did this because he thought that congressional help was lacking.

3:02.8

So in this discussion, we look at what his cabinet was like and how far apart politically were Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton and others, whether they were as close as a modern day Rockefeller Republican and West Belt Democrat would be, or they were as far apart from each other as, say, Alexander Acasio Cortez

3:20.8

and Steve King would be completely opposite sides on left and right. We'll also discuss how cabinets could make a presidency succeed or fail, what makes a good cabinet.

3:29.8

And finally, I ask Lindsay, if she were president, how would she select her cabinet, would she just survey the land of the United States and choose the most competent people, or would she look for loyalty above all else so that the cabinet members don't try to leak things to the press and subtly and sneakily try to destroy her presidency as some cabinet members did in the past.

3:48.8

And I really good look at the inside of American power politics, and I hope you enjoyed this discussion with Lindsay Trevinsky. Lindsay, welcome to the show.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from History Unplugged, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of History Unplugged and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.