meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
The Minds of Madness - True Crime Stories

Episode 179 - Broiled Rats - The Mysterious Disappearance of James Sheaffer

The Minds of Madness - True Crime Stories

themindsofmadness

True Crime, Society & Culture, Documentary

4.46.5K Ratings

🗓️ 3 September 2023

⏱️ 55 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

For most people, a cemetery is a place to pay last respects to a loved one, to grieve a loss, or revisit a bittersweet memory of a happier time.

For others, it’s a place of fear - full of superstitions and terrors.

Whether or not you’re a believer in superstitions, there’s no question that a cemetery isn’t exactly your normal location for a casual meeting. But in the early morning hours of April 3rd, 2013, two people pulled into the Osteen cemetery in Deltona Florida to have a little chat…only one of them left alive.

How to support:
For extra perks including exclusive content, early release, and ad-free episodes -
Go to - Patreon

How to connect:

Website
Instagram
Facebook
Twitter

Please check out our sponsors and help support the podcast:
Zocdoc - Go to zocdoc.com/MADNESS and download the Zocdoc app for FREE. Then find and book a top-rated doctor today. Many are available within 24 hours.
Better Help - This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp - Give online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/MADNESS and get on your way to being your best self.
Babbel - Get up to 55% off your subscription when you go to babbel.com/Madness
PDS Debt - PDS DEBT is offering free debt analysis to our listeners just for completing the quick and easy debt assessment at www.PDSDebt.com/mad
Vessi - Click vessi.com/MADNESS and use code MADNESS for 15% off your entire order! Free shipping to CA, US, AU,JP, TW,KR, SG
Hello Fresh - Go to HelloFresh.com/madness50 and use code madness50 for 50% off, plus your first box ships free!
Manly Bands - There's no better time to invest in a Manly Bands wedding ring than right now. We're offering a 25% discount on all wedding rings at ManlyBands.com with code MADNESS.
Rocket Money - Stop throwing your money away. Cancel unwanted subscriptions and manage your expenses the easy way by going to RocketMoney.com/minds
Liquid IV - Grab your Liquid I.V. Hydration Multiplier Sugar-Free in bulk nationwide at Costco or get 20% off when you go to www.liquid-iv.com and use code MADNESS at checkout.
DAVE - Download Dave today at Dave.com/madness. You could get up to $500 in 5 minutes or less! No credit check. No late fees.

CrimeCon Appearances:
Join us in London (June 10 - 11) or in Orlando (September 22 - 24). And don't forget to quote "MADNESS" to claim your discount.
CrimeCon UK - https://www.crimecon.co.uk
CrimeCon US - https://www.crimecon.com

Special Thanks:
John Brady - Former Volusia County Sheriff’s Office Investigator

Research & Writing:
Nicole Colin & Katherine Thomas - Epigram Literary Group

Editing:
Aiden Wolf

Sources:
jacksonville.com
angelastoldt.net
murderpedia.org
nydailynews.com
nydailynews.com 2
news-journalonline.com
news-journalonline.com 2
news-journalonline.com 3
dailymail.co.uk
drugs.com
insideprison.com
oxygen.com
oxygen.com 2
oxygen.com 3
oxygen.com 4
youtube.com
youtube.com 2
youtube.com 3
youtube.com 4
findagrave.com
lancasteronline.com
orlandosentinel.com
google.ca/maps
zillow.com
zillow.com 2
disabilitysecrets.com
headlinesurfer.com
en.wikipedia.org
treeservicevolusia.com
volusia.org
websleuths.com

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

The opinions expressed in the following episode do not necessarily reflect those of the minds of Madness podcast.

0:07.0

Listener discretion is advised.

0:30.0

For most people, a cemetery is a place to pay last respects to a loved one, to grieve a loss,

0:55.0

or revisit a bittersweet memory of a happier time.

0:59.0

For others, it's a place of fear, full of superstitions and terror.

1:05.0

Imagine a graveyard at night, mistrolling between the headstones, pitch black with no moon inside, or a full moon, even spookier perhaps.

1:16.0

There's a reason this is the setting for countless horror films.

1:21.0

Whether or not you're a believer in superstitions, there's no question that a cemetery is an exactly your normal location for a casual meeting.

1:31.0

But in the early morning hours of April 3rd, 2013, two people pulled into the hosting cemetery in Deltona, Florida to have a quick chat, only one of them left alive.

1:45.0

Join me now, as we entangle the case of James Shaver, a hardworking family man who vanished without a trace, leaving behind a tangled web of secret debts, boxing him into a corner he couldn't escape.

2:01.0

You'll learn how James tried to come up with a plan to solve his money problems and how it cost him his life.

2:11.0

Nestled in southwest Fallujah County in Central Florida is the suburban city of Deltona.

2:18.0

It boasts rolling hills of oak, magnolia, and plenty of lakes, with only about 25 miles in between, separating it from the ocean shore.

2:28.0

It's no wonder that hot and humid Deltona has become one of the largest cities in Central Florida, with a population over 85,000.

2:38.0

While its beautiful parks and wildlife conservation areas are a popular place for bird watchers, there are always, of course, more sinister things to be on the lookout for in Florida, such as eastern rattlesnakes, black widow spiders, and probably what Florida is most known for, its alligators.

2:58.0

But sometimes, the most dangerous creatures are hiding in plain sight, or even just behind the door across the street.

3:08.0

In April 2013, the 1600s square foot Bayesian White 1970s brick home on 1611 horseshoe terrace should have been a big enough place for 42-year-old Angela Stolt and her teenage daughter and son.

3:25.0

But the house that looked so innocuous on the outside was jam-packed with junk on the inside, piled with debris, graffiti on the walls, broken toilets and garbage strewn all around the home.

3:39.0

The house had a large two-car attached garage, with even more junk, as well as several bulging garbage bags.

3:48.0

The home reaked, both from the broken toilets, and because, as Angela told her daughter, a rat had gotten trapped in the oven when it was set to broil.

3:59.0

And then there was the matter of the bulging black garbage bags in the garage, which, considering the state of the house, probably didn't seem so out of place.

4:09.0

Angela told her son that the bags contained the carcass of a rotting deer she'd hit with her car, and that she needed help getting rid of.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from themindsofmadness, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of themindsofmadness and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.