One year when Anthony and I were newly married, I accompanied him to Northern Kentucky for a work conference.

While he spent the day in meetings, I filled my days with other activities.

If you've been listening to us for a while now, you know how I am.

If you're new here, I am a self-proclaimed scaredy cat.

So rather than filling my days with museum explorations or shopping or going to the zoo,

I spent my time ordering room service, watching TV, and staying in my pajamas all behind the safety

of a locked door. Unlike me, the victim of today's case wasn't a scaredy cat. And while in a different city with her husband, who was also attending a conference,

she decided to go sightseeing.

But she never made it to see many of the things she had planned.

Somewhere along the way, she disappeared.

A beloved 50-year-old nurse from Newton, Massachusetts just simply vanished.

For five months, her family frantically

searched for her only for her remains to be found some 600 miles away. This geographical

discrepancy immediately became a central point of contention in the investigation, raising the

question of how she traveled such a significant distance. The case is further complicated by conflicting witness

accounts, the initial focus on her husband as a suspect, and the lack of concrete physical

evidence directly linking a perpetrator to the crime. This cold case has perplexed investigators

and web sleuths for years, and we're still left wondering if it will ever be solved.

This is the case of Judy Smith. You know, I'm going to be able to you know I'm the I'm I'm going to be. Welcome to coffee and cases where we like our coffee hot and our cases cold.

My name is Allison Williams.

And my name is Maggie Damran.

We will be telling stories each week in the hopes that someone out there with any

...