Previously on Bear Brook Season 2, a true crime story.

The jury is listening to you.

You sound like a criminal, not a guy that's made a towel on his name.

The project is not that easy.

I hope you do understand that.

I'm just thinking, this is my easy. I hope you do understand that. I'm just thinking, this is my son.

They're trying to pin this murder on him,

and the word immunity is rolling around in my head.

We had a co-defendant, and if we could dump it on Jason Carroll

to get our guy off, we would have, but we didn't even go in that direction.

I mean, that confession was terrible.

What was the first indication that you got that something was going on?

First indication was Jason was not in house. And it's like, where's Jason? All three of us kids kept asking that.

This is Jackie Carroll Hughes, Jason Carroll's sister, the youngest of four

children in the Carroll family. The night her brother was arrested, Jackie was 12 years old.

That night, Jackie didn't know that police had interrogated her oldest brother over the last four days.

She had no idea he'd been accused of murder.

No idea he'd confessed.

She just knew something was up.

Her parents were acting weird, and her brother wasn't around.

It wasn't until our mom came home the night he was arrested

from the Bedford PD, and we all come up off the couch at the same time, and where's Jason? She goes,

...