4.6 • 640 Ratings
🗓️ 9 July 2025
⏱️ 9 minutes
🧾️ Download transcript
In this bonus episode, Sara and Andrea sit down to revisit the first two cases from Season 2 of SEQUESTERED: the disappearances of Tonetta Carlisle and Brandy Hall.
With fresh eyes and honest questions, they unpack what still doesn’t sit right—from the mysterious witnesses in Tonetta’s case to the conflicting theories around Brandy’s final hours. Why did key players lie? What evidence might still be waiting in an old file or forgotten bag? And who, after all these years, still knows something but hasn’t come forward?
This is a deeper dive into what haunts us, what’s missing, and why these open cases still matter. Send us your thoughts at [email protected]
Click on a timestamp to play from that location
0:00.0 | Welcome back to sequestered season two. |
0:07.0 | I'm Sarah Reed, and this is our first bonus episode where we're taking a moment to talk |
0:12.7 | through the first two cases we've covered, Teneta Carlisle from Chattanooga, Tennessee, and |
0:18.4 | Brandy Hall from Malabar, Florida. |
0:26.8 | And I'm Andrea Clyde. Let's start with Tenetta's case. We intentionally chose to open this season with the Chattanooga case because Sarah, season one of sequestered, centered around |
0:31.7 | your experience as a juror in a Chattanooga trial. We already had so many listeners from the |
0:36.7 | area. It just made sense. |
0:38.5 | Exactly. We hoped that some of those thousands of local listeners might hear Teneta's story |
0:43.5 | and call in a tip. All right, so let's recap and share some of the things that really stood |
0:48.9 | out to us while researching this case. Okay, so if you haven't listened to episode one of season two yet, definitely go back |
0:56.0 | and listen to the full story. |
0:58.0 | But here's a quick snippet. |
0:59.0 | Tenetta was 15 years old walking home from a school in broad daylight, and when she was abducted, |
1:06.0 | at least two witnesses saw it happen. |
1:08.0 | Then just a few days later, the car involved was found, and inside was Jeffrey |
1:13.2 | Jones, the car's owner, dead by suicide from carbon monoxide poisoning. That detail is hard to |
1:20.2 | ignore. His death strongly suggests guilt, but the witnesses didn't just see one man take Tanetta. |
1:26.6 | There were multiple men who jumped out of |
1:29.1 | the tan and yellow vehicle. So who were the others? Right. It's hard to believe that no one has said |
1:35.1 | anything, especially after all these years. You'd think someone would have talked. But honestly, |
1:40.3 | we found so little on this case. There's barely any conversation about it online, not even on Reddit. |
1:47.2 | And another thing that really bothers me, the police didn't connect Taneda's mother's |
... |
Transcript will be available on the free plan in 18 days. Upgrade to see the full transcript now.
Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Road Trip Studios, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.
Generated transcripts are the property of Road Trip Studios and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.
Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.