meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
The Preamble

An Assassin in Utopia with Susan Wels

The Preamble

Sharon McMahon

Government, History, Storytelling, Education

4.915.1K Ratings

🗓️ 24 February 2023

⏱️ 44 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Joining Sharon on Here’s Where It Gets Interesting is Susan Wels, whose new true crime book, An Assassin in Utopia, proves that real life really is stranger than fiction. Stay tuned as we dive into the intimacies of the utopian Oneida cult community–its famous members, its principles, and the unthinkable murder that tarnished its reputation… but not its silverware.


Please note that this episode contains mature content and may not be suitable for young children.


Thank you to our guest, Susan Wels.



Hosted by: Sharon McMahon

Guest: Susan Wels


Executive Producer: Heather Jackson

Audio Producer: Jenny Snyder

Researcher: Valerie Hoback



Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Hello, kids. Welcome. I first of all, today's episode, oh my gosh, I think you're gonna love it. I guarantee you there

0:15.7

will be things in this episode that you are like, what? I just couldn't stop laughing. It made me, it just

0:21.7

really tickled me. I do need to give you a content morning though. We do refer to some subjects that are not

0:26.5

going to be super appropriate for younger children, but I really hope you'll stick around because my

0:32.6

conversation with author Susan Wells is fascinating. Let's dive in. I'm Sharon Mcbath and here's where I

0:42.6

get's interesting. I'm really excited to be chatting with author Susan Wells today. Your book was on my

0:51.3

radar of like, I need to read that. Even before we ever connected, I was fascinated by this topic. First of all, tell us about how you

1:02.9

became interested in Charles Gito and the O'Night Occult. How did this even get on your radar? Well, I went back to

1:13.0

school to get a Master's in History when I was about 40, 41. And in one of my classes, I learned about the

1:19.1

O'Night community. And I was absolutely gobsmacked because this was taking place in Victoria and America. And it was more like what was

1:27.9

happening in the 1960s in the United States in terms of these experimental new communities and utopian societies that broke all of the social

1:37.9

rules. And I had in the back of my head that I would love to write something about the O'Night

1:43.7

community. And I thought if I could find a crime committed by somebody in the United community, I might have a book. The

1:52.1

problem was that the United community was incredibly well thought of by all their neighbors. Nobody committed any crimes that I could

2:02.9

unearth. And then finally, the New York Times put their archives online. And I thought, well, there's a small chance that if a crime was

2:12.3

committed in upstate New York, that the New York Times might report on it. So as a last gasp effort, I typed in O'Night

2:19.4

community crime. And whoa, I got an absolute avalanche of hits. And when I was able to focus on it, it was a presidential

2:29.3

assassination. So I thought, I've got a book. And I spent the next 12 years researching every single aspect of it.

2:36.9

12 years. 12 years. 12 years. My goodness. That is dedication. People in my community are always very interested in how writers research their

2:47.9

book. And 12 years, I'm just going to keep like exclaiming that over and over. What were you doing for 12 years? I mean, like those are some

2:56.9

deep dive suits in. Yes. Well, you know, when I got into the book, you know, I knew that there was a presidential assassination. And I knew that there was the

3:03.8

O'Night community. And literally, it was like opening up a cabinet of curiosities because there were so many sub stories and famous people who linked into this story. And I had to research every one of them because

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Sharon McMahon, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Sharon McMahon and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.