meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Southern Fried True Crime

33: An Inconvenient Woman- Athalia Ponsell Lindsley

Southern Fried True Crime

Erica Kelley

True Crime, Society & Culture, History

4.610.5K Ratings

🗓️ 16 November 2018

⏱️ 54 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

In 1974, a feisty, outspoken woman in St. Augustine, FL became embroiled in a ridiculous feud with her neighbors, one that went public and turned most of the old city against her. Then she was brutally murdered with a machete on her own front porch, in broad daylight. And her murderer was set free.

Sources: https://www.southernfriedtruecrime.com/33-an-inconvenient-woman

If you're interested in reading more about this fascinating and infuriating case, please check out "Murder in St. Augustine: The Mysterious Death of Athalia Ponsell Lindsley" by Elizabeth Randall:

Special thanks to Southern Fried listener, Chadwick, for suggesting this case.

Written, hosted, produced by Erica Kelley
Researched by Erica Kelley
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison-Gamma Radio

Merch | Donate | In the Media:
https://southernfriedtruecrime.com

@southfriedtruth (Twitter) @southernfriedtruecrime (Insta)

https://www.facebook.com/southernfriedtruecrime

https://www.youtube.com/southernfriedtruecrime

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

From January 1, 1976 through the end of March, 1977, the Maturity Trade Area was the site of nine child murders.

0:12.0

Three of those cases are resolved, but the other six cases remain open, with most of these deaths attributed to the as-yet-unidentified Oakland County child killer.

0:24.0

Don't talk to strangers as a long-form podcast focused on this series of unresolved child murders.

0:30.0

Join us as we explore the stories of these young victims, the impact on their families and the community, and what happened to the investigation into these crimes.

0:40.0

Subscribe to Don't Talk to Strangers on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, or your favorite pod catcher.

0:55.0

Southern Fried true crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used.

1:04.0

Listener discretion is advised.

1:08.0

The famous quote, well-behaved women seldom make history, is often attributed to the likes of Eleanor Roosevelt or other noted figures.

1:18.0

But it was actually written by historian Laurel Thatcher Ulrich in 1976.

1:24.0

That was two years after the death of a thalya pawn cell lensley, a woman who took St. Augustine Florida by storm a few years earlier.

1:33.0

A beautiful and interesting woman, a thalya moved from Jacksonville to St. Augustine with her ailing mother seeking a new place to settle, and one where she had fond childhood memories.

1:45.0

She soon found that though she might be old money, she wasn't St. Augustine old money, and that made her an outsider from the beginning.

1:53.0

She has been called a shrew, as well as a washed up husband, and many other demeaning, agist and sexist names over the years.

2:02.0

But she was actually quite intellectual and a feminist, though a conservative.

2:08.0

She was also a socialite and politically ambitious, but she would not suffer fools quietly.

2:14.0

As her widower put it, she simply had more courage than discretion.

2:19.0

It was that outspoken courage that would lead to her brutal murder and broad daylight on the front porch of her home.

2:26.0

She was hacked to death and nearly decapitated with a machete, and it was her reputation in St. Augustine, as well as the city's affection for her murderer that would lead to the unimagine.

2:36.0

She would lead to the unimaginable miscarriage of justice that set him free.

2:41.0

Welcome to Episode 33, an inconvenient woman, the murder of Athalia Poncelle Linsley.

2:49.0

Founded in 1565 by Spanish explorers, St. Augustine is the oldest European established settlement that has been continuously inhabited in the continental United States.

3:01.0

It was 20 years before Ronaque was established in Virginia, 42 years before Jamestown, and 55 years before the Pilgrims established what is known as America's hometown in Plymouth, Massachusetts.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Erica Kelley, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Erica Kelley and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.