meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
When Diplomacy Fails Podcast

1956 1.15: Socialism Stays

When Diplomacy Fails Podcast

Zack Twamley

19th Century, 20th Century, International Relations, Politics, Thirty Years' War, Korean War, 18th Century, First World War, Phd, 17th Century, European History, History, War

4.8773 Ratings

🗓️ 29 February 2024

⏱️ 37 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

1956 Episode 1.15 examines the final moments of Imre Nagy, as the Soviet noose tightened around him.


But the Kremlin was not safe yet. Of particular concern to Moscow and to the Hungarians was the stance of Yugoslavia, as its embassy in Budapest provided asylum to Imre Nagy and 40 other individuals responsible for guiding and leading the momentarily independent Hungarian state. The revolution may have been crushed within a few days, but it was evidently not going to be so simple to remove the memory of Nagy. Although normal Hungarian citizens couldn’t know of his fate, even when he was tricked into leaving this safe haven in late November, behind the scenes the Soviet-Yugoslav diplomacy was only serving to heighten tensions in the communist world.


In addition, the Chinese, soon to visit the Eastern satellites in January 1957, had their own comments to make on the events in Hungary. The Chinese conclusion, and the conclusion which has largely survived as canon to this day, was that Vladislav Gomulka had only gone so far, whereas Imre Nagy had gone far too far in bringing reform to his country. It was not acceptable, in the Chinese mind, that reform came at the expense of Soviet power and stability – a national road to socialism was to be admired, but this road could be bumpy, and on occasion, fraught with danger.


Also worth considering was the American perspective – Eisenhower’s administration was thoroughly distracted by events in Egypt, and while he and his Secretary of State John Foster Dulles never really intended to intervene with force in Hungary, the unofficial state organs like Radio Free Europe ensured that the American or at least the Western approach and intentions remained unclear to Hungarians, who felt encouraged to challenge the Soviet domination, and were then bitterly disappointed when no Western aid materialised. Suez was of course a convenient excuse for American non-intervention, yet for Eisenhower’s new ‘rollback’ policy towards the Soviet Union, it was important to blame the Anglo-French-Israeli attack upon Egypt to the end...


At the pinnacle of our narrative was the fate of Nagy and his circle. Two years after the revolution had been put down, Nagy was executed. Even in his final moments he refused to admit error and to denounce what had been done. He went to the gallows courageously, confident that no matter what occurred after his death, one day, he would be reburied, and Hungary would be free. His legacy was to inspire Hungarian politicians and a tacit policy of non-violent resistance to Soviet rule throughout the next few decades. His words would prove correct – Imre Nagy’s reburial in June 1989 signalled the end of Soviet domination, the collapse of the Soviet Union and the end of the Cold War all at once. Nagy’s death and rehabilitation put to bed the fallout of Khrushchev’s secret speech, and it also concludes our first part of 1956. Next time, we’ll begin our examination of that other significant narrative which 1956 provided, as we count down to the Suez Crisis.

Get bonus content on Patreon

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Hello and welcome history friends, all to 1956, episode 1.15.

0:29.2

This here is the final episode of our first phase in the series and a huge thanks must go out to all of you who have gotten in touch over the last few weeks to let me know you've enjoyed this revitalization of this fascinating series.

0:44.6

It seems this second go-round of 1956 initially caught you by surprise, but now many episodes are available with many more to come.

0:53.9

And it seems like most of you have caught up through some excessive binging,

0:57.7

so well done and welcome.

0:59.7

We are far from finished with the story of 1956 just yet,

1:03.9

so make sure you tune in next time when we begin our coverage of the different roads,

1:08.4

which led in time to the Suez Crisis.

1:11.7

Here, though, we still have some important and fascinating aspects of the Hungarian

1:15.6

revolution to cover. While we watched the whole thing come apart last time, we didn't

1:20.1

spend as much time as I would have liked, examining what other powers thought of the Hungarian

1:24.6

episode. In this episode, then, we'll not only look at how the event was

1:29.0

portrayed in different countries, including some Eastern block ones, will also finish the story

1:33.8

of Imre Naj and Company, and will look at Hungary for the first time from the perspective of the

1:38.9

United States, where President Eisenhower was increasingly distracted by the upcoming election,

1:44.1

and, oh yeah, that little scuffle going down in Egypt.

1:47.4

The story of Hungary teaches us an important lesson regarding Soviet policy.

1:52.5

Hungary was to prove the nail in the coffin of leftist mobilization under the Soviet banner.

1:58.2

While Budapest was crushed, the Hungarians became the critical ingredient

2:02.6

in the undermining of Soviet influence in the West. Such a fact was only a consolation prize

2:08.1

to those Hungarians who were now faced with a return to the old ways, but it was a fact nonetheless

2:13.4

and an important watershed moment in Soviet history. If you're ready then to tackle our final

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Zack Twamley, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Zack Twamley and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.