meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Open to Debate

#148 - Should Net Neutrality Be Saved?

Open to Debate

Open to Debate

Education, Society & Culture, News, Government, Politics

4.52.1K Ratings

🗓️ 27 April 2018

⏱️ 51 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Motion: Preserve Net Neutrality: All Data is Created Equal. What if a single policy could impact American democracy, culture, and competitiveness? What if that policy might either empower citizens and consumers, or burden them? And what if the decision on that policy sparked a frenzy of legislative proposals, judicial challenges, and citizen outrage, all across the country? The Federal Communications Commission’s decision to end net neutrality regulations has fueled a national debate about the future of the internet. Adopted in 2015, net neutrality promised to preserve the democratic spirit of the web by ensuring that all data would be treated equally, regardless of where it originated. Under these regulations, internet service providers (ISPs) such as Verizon, Comcast and AT&T, the corporate giants who deliver the internet into our homes, could supply web infrastructure, but could not preference how data passed through it. Denying them that power, supporters argue, remains critical to ensuring that users and content-creators can discover ideas and information without censorship, or charges, from these prospective gatekeepers. After all, no person should have to pay for every video streamed on YouTube; no startup should be hobbled against established companies who buy faster access to consumers; and no minority voice should have its ideas throttled by wealthier interests. On the other hand, net neutrality opponents argue that the genius of the Internet has been its individually driven, organic development, free from the heavy hand of so-called net neutrality. These burdensome regulations constitute dangerous governmental overreach, stifle innovation, and spike costs for both consumers and providers. The result, they maintain, will be a less interesting, less democratic, less innovative web. Moreover, Americans will enjoy uninterrupted access to their favorite sites – without net neutrality – because ISPs make more money from an open, rather than closed, internet. Consequently, the backlash against the FCC’s decision is overblown, and ending net neutrality is the right policy for the future of America’s internet. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Between you and the internet stands a company, maybe it is called Verizon or AT&T or Comcast

0:09.5

or Cox, that last piece of the pipeline connecting you to the world, it belongs to them,

0:16.6

your internet service provider.

0:18.7

And in that inescapable relationship, what rights belong to you?

0:23.4

What rights belong to them?

0:26.0

Net neutrality is the idea, as most people understand it, that ISPs are practically public

0:31.4

utilities and should have almost no right to limit where you can go on the internet or

0:36.6

the speed at which content creators can get their data to you.

0:40.8

They cannot, for example, make you pay more to connect with Facebook or shut you out of

0:44.8

Facebook altogether.

0:46.0

They can't make Netflix pay extra to move its video at a decent speed, a cost that would

0:50.9

truly get passed on to you.

0:52.8

The Obama administration liked Net neutrality and made it the rule.

0:57.2

The Trump administration repealed it.

0:59.6

Its main argument being that Net neutrality is a soft idea, it is unnecessary regulation

1:05.4

and it is detrimental to innovation.

1:08.4

We think this sounds like it has the makings of a debate, so let's have it.

1:11.8

Yes or no to this statement.

1:14.3

Preserve Net neutrality, all data is created equal.

1:18.9

I'm John Donvan and I stand between two teams of two, as always, our debate will go in

1:24.1

three rounds and then our audience here at the Northwestern Pritzker School of Law

1:28.1

in Chicago will choose the winner.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Open to Debate, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Open to Debate and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.