meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Mormon Stories Podcast

1291: Surviving Spiritual Abuse and Suicidality at BYU-Idaho Faculty - Ryan & Holly Nielsen Pt. 5

Mormon Stories Podcast

Dr. John Dehlin

Religion & Spirituality

4.55.7K Ratings

🗓️ 6 April 2020

⏱️ 66 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

For today’s Mormon Stories Podcast episode we interview Ryan Nielsen and Holly Parson Nielsen, who were both raised as devout Mormons in Rexburg, Idaho. After marriage, Ryan worked as full-time BYU-Idaho faculty for twelve years in the Department of Music, while Holly taught middle school art.

Important themes for this episode include:

  • Ryan's perfectionism and guilt/shame as a Mormon youth.
  • Holly's closeted feminism as a Mormon youth and adult.
  • Holly and Ryan learning to listen to their own inner voices, which also involved navigating a religious faith crisis.
  • Navigating BYU-Idaho while one is full time faculty, and in a mixed-faith marriage. This story includes harassment from bishopric over maintaining continuing faculty endorsement (mostly related to Holly’s resignation from the Mormon church.
  • An insider’s view of BYU-Idaho administration, including difficulties dealing with BYU-Idaho executives related to Title IX issues (e.g., sexual misconduct of Mormon ecclesiastical leaders towards BYU-Idaho students and faculty).
  • Navigating and healing from religion-based depression, including suicidality.
  • Deconstructing Mormon literalism and reconstructing a nuanced worldview.
  • Learning to choose love over ideas.
Additional Resources mentioned in the episodes:
  • Ryan's AMAZING faith crisis/transition Reading/Podcast list can be found here, and has also been included below, after the video and audio links.  This is probably the most impressive and thoughtful resources list I've ever seen for Mormon/religious faith transitions.
  • Holly's Art: https://www.artbyholly.com/abstract.html  -- This link goes straight to the art Holly has done related to her faith transition, and her reclamation of motherhood.
  • Ryan's Music: http://www.ryannielsenmusic.com/music -- This link goes straight to the music portion of Ryan's website. Several pieces there are related to my faith transition, including "Prayer for Peace" and "Requiem."
  • Support Ryan!  Ryan has written a 9 movement suite that explores his experience of a faith crisis, through the lens of the life of Elijah Abel.  It's time to get this recorded. Ryan has created a GoFundMe campaign to raise funds for the project.  Please support this worthy project!

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Thank you for joining us today on Mormon Stories Podcast. If you value this podcast and want to see it continue, please become a monthly supporter at MormonStories.org.

0:14.0

So yeah, so I met with him and he assured me that it would not affect my employability there at all. And he even promised me that he would have basically that he would have my back.

0:28.0

And then he offered to say a prayer and he said a prayer that was just so beautiful and thoughtful and kind and I still remember how that felt and loved it.

0:41.0

And he said basically it was just you know praying for for just the well-being of my family and support and strength and love for me and it was just a really beautiful gesture on his part that was a really positive experience.

0:57.0

And so I started moving forward feeling like okay well Kim Clark says I'm fine so I should be fine.

1:03.0

Yeah, you know, I place case closed case closed right. I will say when Holly resigned before I jump into that it was really really hard for me when she resigned.

1:19.0

Well largely because I felt like even though even though she I support her leaving the church I know that she needs to do that and I and I

1:31.0

and even though I share many of her concerns right that still are ceiling.

1:37.0

You know that's our marriage and there was something about that that felt really hard to me she was canceling she was in because that's what she was doing was cancel right and did you believe in the ceiling not necessarily at that point I was like I don't know I don't think I did I don't know there's also the fear that she don't go off the end go off the deep end to worship you know be an unfaithful like that's the common belief that I

2:06.0

that a wife would have about a husband who leaves the church right resigns I don't even remember I think I feel I've had to

2:18.0

fleeting thoughts about that but nothing substantive like that hasn't been a big part of my mental energy okay.

2:26.0

But it was really hard and it was also really hard that again we just don't talk about these things no one asked me what that was like for me no one meaning who

2:38.0

would you have wanted to ask her parents how you doing Ryan you know like anyone just anyone it felt really lonely so but it was

2:52.0

just we don't talk about this thing you know yeah so I just wanted to add that and that once she resigned she got the church sent her a

3:06.0

letter and the letter basically threatened her with eternal consequences and the minute she read that she just took the

3:16.0

little she looked right at me said now I know I made the right decision and just tossed it in a garbage and that was it I recycled it.

3:22.0

Pots in the recycling excuse me yeah that's right. So that's right so that was really yeah I I

3:32.0

I when different things are coming up and new things are frustrating with the church that come up I'm surprised

3:42.0

that it gets reprised that was another moment that I thought really guys you're going to sit here and try to shame me and threaten me to come back.

3:50.0

Do you know that's part of the whole problem anyway so that was and it was just please come on and I was really heartbroken because I had hoped that it would be some kind of a generous

4:02.0

something but it wasn't it was an awful letter so I was I was sad about that oh were there pamphlets yeah and who said it well the church like from the church

4:14.0

headquarters yeah I don't remember all right it's it's sort of that letter that says I don't know if they still send it but it's just like you're

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Dr. John Dehlin, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Dr. John Dehlin and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.