meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Catholic Answers Live

#12620 Why Two Catholic Masses? Answers on Latin Mass AMA: Dropped Calls - Jimmy Akin

Catholic Answers Live

Catholic Answers

Christianity, Religion & Spirituality

4.8 • 2.2K Ratings

🗓️ 7 March 2026

⏱️ 55 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Why does the Catholic Church have both the Traditional Latin Mass and the modern form of the Mass—and how should you explain the difference without getting pulled into “liturgy wars”? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists address this common question before diving into a wide range of topics. They explore whether charging interest is still considered usury, how just war theory applies to rebellions, and how historical cases like the Knights Templar fit with Church law. The episode also explains the role of baptism in justification, offers arguments against naturalism, and gives practical advice for strengthening Catholic marriages. Additional questions include how to understand Peter’s denial of Jesus and what it means for salvation. A rich discussion covering liturgy, moral theology, and everyday Catholic life. Questions Covered: 05:32 – I attend the Tridentine Mass Almost exclusively at my ‘local’ FSSP parish. I have a friend seeking the Catholic Church who asked me ‘why do you have two different masses in the Western Rite? Why don’t you just attend the regular English one?’   I often say that I am drawn to the beauty and simplicity of it. How do we respond to this simply without dragging them into the so-called ‘liturgy wars’? How do we respond given the restrictions placed on the older masses? Basically, how do we address this difference to those outside the church? Do I just keep a response about ‘preferences of the faithful’?  11:46 – The Church has been quite vocal against usury over the centuries. Is it still defined as any lending of money at interest? How does this notion square with the idea of a variable money supply? Would things like bank accounts, bonds, cds or stocks still be considered illicit? Has there been any recent guidance from the magisterium?  19:02 – Does just war theory apply to rebellions? Historically, I’m thinking of Irish wars against the British Empire and slave revolts of African-descended peoples in the Americas, including during the U.S. Civil War. What would be the conditions of jus ad bellum in cases like these or any other group dealing with an oppressor?  28:46 – Canon 7 of Chalcedon forbids clergy and monks from war and holding secular office. How then did the Knights Templar, and bishops such as the bishop of Andorra, who also holds title of Co-Prince of Andorra, not violate this?  34:03 – How does baptism fit with “faith alone working through love?” Can someone with “faith alone working through love” be initially justified apart from baptism?  19:44 – What do you think is the most convincing argument/thought exercise against naturalism/empricism (or at least what the average indifferent secular person thinks they believe).  46:29 – What is your best advice for a married Catholic couple to strengthen their bond in marriage? Your stories about you and Renee are always so beautiful (the blue birds especially). Also thanks for being a Catholic cowboy. I grew up Southern Baptist, and seeing a southern Catholic gentleman do apologetics is really cool.  50:51 –  Peter denied Jesus 3 times. After the cock crows three times he ran away in shame. What if he falls, hits his head and dies after this? Would his soul be in danger of damnation?

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Buying or selling your home, real estate for life can connect you with a pro-life real estate agent.

0:05.2

When Real Estate for Life receives a referral fee, they donate 65% to Catholic Answers.

0:11.5

Learn more at realestateforlife.org. Welcome back. Catholic Answers live, Jimmy Aiken, our guest, and all the questions in,

0:35.0

we've got a whole bunch of questions from social media, internet, YouTube.

0:40.0

I mean, I meant to say, certainly I'm sure that some of these came from YouTube, but I meant to say email.

0:46.2

Some people send them in via email.

0:48.2

Jimmy Aiken, thank you for coming back for another hour.

0:51.6

Yeah, my pleasure.

0:52.6

Happy to do so.

0:54.4

Talking with you just a little bit at the break that deep, deep from the first hour had

0:58.3

some, had the question about AI and consciousness and could a computer ever become

1:04.2

conscious, that kind of thing.

1:05.6

And you wanted to add to your remarks from the first hour.

1:08.7

Yeah, I just thought I'd mentioned something.

1:11.9

This is not a, of crushing, you know, significance, but it's just a little personal story. I have various

1:19.9

ideas that I keep for fiction that I might write someday, and I almost never write fiction

1:26.9

because I've got too much

1:28.5

nonfiction I need to write. This is going back to our question about time management and the

1:33.7

economic problem of how to use which talents you got from last hour. So I very almost never write

1:39.8

fiction. But I do have ideas, not even sometimes keep lists of them, but I had an idea that basically duplicates the Chinese room, and I developed it independently. I didn't even know about the Chinese room at the time, but I duplicated it with a modification that actually makes the point even clearer. Because in the

2:03.6

Chinese room, you've got a person, a human who is conscious of something that is applying the

2:10.6

rules to select what's an appropriate response to which query.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Catholic Answers, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Catholic Answers and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.