There are more ways than ever to listen to History Daily ad-free.

Listen with Wondry Plus in the Wondry app.

As a member of NoisorPlus at noisor.com or in Apple Podcasts,

or you can get all of History Daily plus other fantastic history podcasts at IntoHistory.com.

Thank you. It's September 10, 1608 in the small English colony of Jamestown, Virginia.

29-year-old John Smith trudges through the muddy streets of the tiny settlement.

Jamestown is perched on the edge of a wide river.

Laid out in the shape of a triangle, with a gun position at each corner, his handful of hastily built thatched huts and houses squat behind high wooden walls. John has just spent seven weeks out in the

wilderness that lies beyond these walls. He set out looking for

gold and a passageway to the Pacific Ocean, but he found neither. And if that wasn't disappointment

enough, what he discovered in Jamestown on his return has him shocked and horrifying. John is one of

just over a hundred colonists who left England almost two years ago.

Most of the first settlers have since died, though,

but newcomers from home have bolstered their numbers,

and John still hopes the colony can be a success, but only if changes are made.

Right now, the streets are almost empty.

Men peer out of the dark and cramped houses as John passes, their faces pinched with hunger.

There's an unmistakable smell of death and disease in the air.

So John strides into the largest building in the settlement.

In this low-ceilinged room, choked with smoke from an open fire,

a group of exhausted, pale men sit around a table.

This is Jamestown's council, and it needs a new leader.

...