meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Catholic Answers Live

#11748 Ask Me Anything - Jimmy Akin

Catholic Answers Live

Catholic Answers

Christianity, Religion & Spirituality

4.82.2K Ratings

🗓️ 5 July 2024

⏱️ 55 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Questions Covered: 02:22 – I was at a gun show in Idaho not long ago and one of the vendors was a born again Christian group handing out Jack Chick tracts. I walked past them fairly quickly, not because I didn’t want to engage but because I was trying to catch up to my son-in-law. As I was walking back up the aisle they were on I was distracted by a vendor selling antique rifles, some going back as far as the Revolutionary War, when someone said to me “thank you for your service!” I turned to my left to see a guy, about my age, and he repeated himself. I thanked him but explained I hadn’t been in the military. He looked surprised then said something about the color of my eyes (hazel/green) and when I realized who I was talking to I knew I was stuck. It was the Pastor of the group handing out the JC Tracts. Long story short he asked me if I knew I was saved. I said yes. He asked if I knew I was going to heaven I said it’s my hope, but that ultimately was up to me. Then he commences to break out a green, hand held, KJV military Bible (one that I have), reads me some scripture, and asks if I will pray with him. I said of course! We commence the praying and I realize this was my altar call…I was being made born again. After the prayer he congratulated me…and I started to feel uneasy. It’s bothered me since. I know I hadn’t renounced my Catholic faith because the prayer was pretty generic, but there’s a part of me that thinks I made a mistake. Did I, or am I being overly scrupulous? 05:47 – How did authorship work in the ancient and medieval periods? For example, I heavily doubt that Homer made a fortune selling copies of The Iliad and The Odyssey or that Plato sold copies of The Republic. How were ancient writings circulated? I imagine having to hand copy every word from every scroll would put a damper on how accessible they would be in markets. Did every individual who copies the Odyssey have to copy down “Written by Homer” with it? What if someone wanted to take the same Odyssey and pass it off as their original work? Also, how would the average man living in these periods know which authors (who are trying to pass information down) are genuine and which authors are hacks? 16:26 – I just learned about Hilazon blue. Is there a checklist of all the things needed for rebuilding the Third Temple, and what’s left? 18:36 – You have mentioned before that God could have created a universe that appeared to be eternal, that is, without a beginning (I hope I have that right…). I do not understand this, as being “created” would seem to require a beginning (otherwise, God would not need to create it). Or are you saying that it merely has the “appearance” of always existing, but was created? In which case, does that mean that God is deliberately deceiving? 22:01 – Why do we restrict Protestants from receiving the Eucharist except in certain limited circumstances (grave necessity)? Children baptized into the Catholic faith are able to receive the Eucharist before being confirmed. There is no difference (as far as I am aware) between a valid Catholic baptism and a valid Protestant baptism, so there is no ontological difference between a baptized-but-unconfirmed Catholic and a baptized-but-unconfirmed Protestant. Belief cannot be the answer, since many Protestants (while in RCIA and before their confirmation) have the same faith as Catholics. Is it prudential? 28:34 – Why is the Protestant account for the canon of scripture untenable? 34:05 – How will we be able to interact in heaven with our loved ones without a body? (That is, until they are resurrected.) 35:44 – John 20:22, our Lord breathed on the apostles and gave them the Holy Spirit. Thomas was not with them. When did Thomas receive the Holy Spirit? 40:47 – What is a good source to use to get authentic news from what th…

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

I'm going to Welcome back to Cathay Gansers Live. I am Cy Kelly, your host for this Independence Day edition of

0:22.0

Cathay G Catholic Answers Live.

0:24.0

It's an open form.

0:25.0

Jimmy Aiken is our guest, but it's a, no, it's not open.

0:28.0

I keep saying open form, that's the old language.

0:30.0

I'm supposed to be contemporary.

0:31.0

It's an ask me anything with Jimmy

0:32.8

Aiken but it's an internet version. All the questions have come from the

0:35.9

internet. Jimmy Aiken, of course senior apologist here at Catholic

0:39.5

Answers and the proprietor of Jimmy Aiken's mysterious world.

0:43.0

Thank you for coming back for another hour, Jimmy.

0:46.0

Yeah, no problem.

0:48.0

Now, at the beginning of last hour, you mentioned things that Americans used to celebrate our independence day. You mentioned burgers and

0:55.8

barbecues, I don't know, maybe, and flags. And you mentioned fireworks? Yeah, you didn't mention guns. And I was surprised you didn't mention guns and I was surprised you didn't mention

1:03.4

guns because some people do you like guns to celebrate the 4th of July like firing them off like

1:10.5

Yosemite Sam into the sky? Yeah.

1:12.8

Oh.

1:13.8

I was once watching a, this was a comedy show.

1:17.2

I think it was the kids in the hall.

1:18.7

It was some Canadian comedy show, sketch comedy show,

1:22.0

where they had a sketch in the Philippines and one of their main

1:26.0

characters who was a Canadian was at like a restaurant in the Philippines and the people there were thinking he was an American.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Catholic Answers, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Catholic Answers and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.