meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Catholic Answers Live

#11307 Is It Mary, Mother of God or Mother of Jesus? - Colin Donovan

Catholic Answers Live

Catholic Answers

Christianity, Religion & Spirituality

4.82.2K Ratings

🗓️ 31 August 2023

⏱️ 55 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Open Forum – Questions Covered: 06:15 – My daughter is a lapsed Catholic and her issue is the problem of evil. What’s the best way to explain this? 16:00 – My husband and I were lukewarm Catholics when we got married. I’ve gotten closer to faith while he’s gotten further away. What does obedience to him look like in our situation? 24:39 – Does canon 1404 mean that no one can judge the pope except for God? 32:21 – Do we know what Jesus and the temple teachers were discussing in Luke 2? 34:12 – Why doesn’t the Church just admit that Joseph and Mary had other children? 43:38 – How is a rite of passage like a Quinceanera intermingled with the mass? Are there official guidelines for it? 47:39 – If Jesus and Mary are in their physical bodies in heaven, would this also mean that the saints are too? 51:12 – How do I explain the title of Mary, Mother of God to my protestant friends? Shouldn’t it be, Mother of Jesus? …

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Hello, and welcome to Catholic Dance's live. Thanks so much for being here with us on this Thursday afternoon. We've got two hours of open form. I'm

0:22.8

Sy Kelly. I'll be your host and second hour Jimmy Aiken will be here this hour. Colin Donovan is our guest. Vice President of theology at the

0:31.4

EWTN Global Catholic Network and a member of the Pontifical International Marien Academy. Colin Donovan, thanks for being here.

0:38.7

That's good to be back as always. And how does that pontifical International Marien Academy gig pay about us? Well not quite as good as

0:47.8

EWTN, but also zero. Okay, yeah, but congratulations. Well, thank you. I mean, it's it's something of a mixed blessing. It basically took five years to deliver the

1:02.4

certificate to me for a lifetime appointment. So at least it doesn't need renew or I'll never see that. Okay, so you won't be having to go to the Vatican DMV to get renewed there. No, no, they wanted me to come

1:15.7

over because they make a deal at the end of Congresses of the of the Pontifical Academy, but you know, with COVID and everything I couldn't. So they

1:24.2

just decided to ship it over and as people saw Bishop Reica so graciously came and delivered it to me here about two weeks ago. So slow boat.

1:35.7

8883187884 is our number. You're welcome to ask whatever you like, but Marien theology is important. This has been an important part of your life as a

1:45.7

theologian. Well, it's been a certainly important part of my life personally in my own faith journey as I I've explained the number of articles in our press release and so on from EWTN.

1:58.4

And appointed out that, you know, the first sisters who taught me up in Saskatoon were the members of the community founded by Alphonse Radisbonus. So Mary, our lady,

2:10.5

miraculous medal in particular, but also the emphasized Fatima in those days, which I hate to say was the late 1950s. So that tells you how old I am. When there was great

2:22.7

expectations of all, you know, the Fatima news coming out in 1960 and the Pope was going to explain it to everybody. And of course, that didn't happen because Pope John 23rd said this does not concern my time. And I think we understand that it concerned our days and be in the

2:40.7

certificate of John Paul II. And really, even what we're continuing to see happening in the world with the battle between good and evil, especially over marriage and family as Sister Lucia pointed out to Cardinal Cofara at one point. So, yeah.

2:56.7

And the theological part of that is something that, as I became more theologically oriented in my thinking and my desire to read that was always a significant part of that whether it was the

3:08.7

writings of St. Alphonse Lagoury, the glories of Mary or our other authors, you know, Louie Demontfort certainly and even Maximilian Colby, his explanation of the magnetic conception. There's a great, there are many great writings in Maryology.

3:27.7

And I think, although the title of the discipline is sort of off-putting, especially to our non-catholic brothers and sisters, if you only reflect for a minute on the scriptural data and the proximity of our lady to the mission of Christ and that all of this had to have been

3:46.7

filled from all eternity by the Father, it gives you a clue as to what Mary's role in, not as a dumb instrument and, you know, in the hand of God to accomplish these things, but as an active human person making decisions, cooperating with grace, bringing and effecting things, including the beginning of our Lord's public ministry, which he accepted that she

4:13.7

did, even though in the eternal knowledge of God that wasn't to have been the moment in the temporal allowances of God, it was. And so there's so much there that we can intuit about God himself and his relationship with human beings in that most perfect of relationships with the human being who was not also the divine son.

4:38.7

It certainly makes her very distinctive in that, unlike he, she was pure creature on yet utterly faithful.

4:48.7

And it's just so beautiful, a beautiful person. I'm so happy. It really is a beautiful thing to hear you talk about her as not a dumb instrument, but as a person who lived a life and that life that she lived as a beautiful life.

5:04.7

And I think, you know, it's important to realize that we have a personal relationship with Jesus. This is always mentioned, especially by our evangelical friends.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Catholic Answers, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Catholic Answers and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.